331+ free tools. No sign-up. No hidden fees. Explore the toolkit

Fixed vs Adjustable-Rate Mortgage: Which Is Better?

By Ali Husnain

Fixed vs adjustable-rate mortgage: which is better? On a $400,000 loan, a fixed rate of 7.11% costs $2,690.83 a month for 30 years, while a 5/1 ARM at 6.00% costs $2,398.20 a month for five years — then adjusts. This guide compares both options with real numbers, including what happens when the ARM's rate rises. To see what an adjustable rate does to your own payment, run the numbers with an ARM mortgage calculator.

Free calculator

Try the free Mortgage Calculator →

Enter your loan amount, rate and term to see your monthly payment — then compare fixed and ARM rates side by side.

Compare my mortgage options
Save to Pinterest
Disclaimer: This guide is general education, not financial advice. Mortgage rates, ARM caps and loan terms vary by lender, and the figures here are estimates based on the assumptions shown — a lender or mortgage broker can give you numbers for your own situation.

The Short Answer

A fixed-rate mortgage locks your interest rate — and your monthly payment — for the whole life of the loan. An adjustable-rate mortgage (ARM) starts with a lower rate for a fixed introductory period, then adjusts up or down with the market. On a $400,000 loan, a 30-year fixed mortgage at 7.11% costs $2,690.83 a month in principal and interest, every month, for 30 years. A 5/1 ARM at 6.00% costs $2,398.20 a month for the first five years — $292.63 a month less — and then the rate adjusts, and the payment can rise substantially.

Which is better depends on how long you will keep the loan. If you will stay in the home for many years, or you want a payment that never changes, the fixed rate is the safer choice. An ARM only makes sense if you are confident you will sell or refinance before the rate adjusts — or if you can comfortably afford the payment even after it adjusts upward. This guide works through the same $400,000 loan both ways, including what happens in year six, so you can judge the trade-off with real numbers instead of a hunch.

How a Fixed-Rate Mortgage Works

A fixed-rate mortgage is the simplest home loan there is. The interest rate is set when you close, and it never changes. The principal and interest payment never changes either. On a $400,000 loan at 7.11% for 30 years, that payment is $2,690.83 a month — in year one, in year fifteen, and in year thirty. Your total cost is knowable on day one: over 30 years you pay $968,697.19 in total, of which $568,697.19 is interest.

What does change over time is how each payment is split. Early on, most of the payment is interest, because the balance is large; as the balance shrinks, more of each payment goes to principal. On the $400,000 loan at 7.11%, the first payment is $2,370.00 of interest and only $320.83 of principal. By the end of year five, the borrower has paid $161,449.53 in total but only $23,034.35 of principal — the balance is still $376,965.65. That slow start is normal for any long-term loan, and it is why the first years of a mortgage build equity slowly. The Amortization Schedule Calculator shows the split payment by payment.

The 7.11% rate in this guide is the average 30-year fixed rate in Freddie Mac's Primary Mortgage Market Survey for the week ending November 12, 2026. Your rate will differ based on your credit score, down payment and lender — run your own numbers in the Mortgage Calculator before deciding.

The 15-Year Fixed Alternative

Before comparing fixed with adjustable, it is worth knowing the other fixed-rate option: the 15-year loan. In the same Freddie Mac survey, the average 15-year fixed rate was 6.45%. On a $400,000 loan, a 15-year fixed mortgage at 6.45% costs $3,473.44 a month — $782.61 a month more than the 30-year fixed at 7.11%. But the total interest is only $225,219.94, against $568,697.19 for the 30-year loan: a saving of $343,477.25.

The 15-year loan is the cheapest way to borrow if you can afford the payment, and it builds equity far faster. The catch is the payment itself — $782.61 a month more, every month, with no flexibility. Many borrowers choose the 30-year loan and pay extra principal when they can afford it, which captures some of the interest saving without locking in the higher payment. The Mortgage Payoff Calculator shows what extra payments do to a 30-year loan's timeline and total interest.

How an Adjustable-Rate Mortgage Works

An ARM has two phases. During the initial fixed period, the rate is locked — just like a fixed-rate loan — for a set number of years. After that, the rate adjusts at regular intervals, usually once a year, based on market conditions. The name tells you the structure: a 5/1 ARM is fixed for the first 5 years, then adjusts once a year. A 7/1 ARM is fixed for 7 years; a 10/1 for 10 years.

When an ARM adjusts, the new rate is the index plus the margin. The index is a published market rate that moves with the economy — most ARMs today are tied to the Secured Overnight Financing Rate (SOFR). The margin is a fixed markup the lender sets when you take out the loan, typically around 2 to 3 percentage points, and it never changes. If the index is 5% and your margin is 2.5%, your adjusted rate is 7.5%. If the index later rises to 6%, your rate rises to 8.5%. The rate you pay after the fixed period is therefore not predictable — it follows the market.

Caps limit how far the rate can move. A typical cap structure is 2/2/5: the rate can rise at most 2 percentage points at the first adjustment, at most 2 points at each later adjustment, and at most 5 points above the starting rate over the life of the loan. These are typical figures, not universal ones — exact caps vary by loan, and some ARMs have different structures, so always read the cap terms on your own loan documents. Caps soften the blow, but they do not prevent a large increase: on a 5/1 ARM starting at 6.00%, a 5-point lifetime cap allows the rate to reach 11%.

Worked Example: A $400,000 Loan — Fixed vs 5/1 ARM

Take a $400,000 loan and compare the two options side by side over the first five years: a 30-year fixed mortgage at 7.11%, and a 5/1 ARM at 6.00% for its five-year fixed period.

 30-year fixed at 7.11%5/1 ARM at 6.00%
Monthly payment (principal & interest)$2,690.83$2,398.20
Total paid in the first 5 years$161,449.53$143,892.13
Interest paid in the first 5 years$138,415.18$116,109.56
Principal paid in the first 5 years$23,034.35$27,782.57
Loan balance after 5 years$376,965.65$372,217.43
Payment after the fixed period$2,690.83 (unchanged)Adjusts with the market

The ARM saves $17,557.41 in the first five years ($161,449.53 minus $143,892.13) — about $292.63 a month for 60 months. That is the ARM's pitch, and it is real money. But look at the last two rows of the table for the surprise: the ARM borrower also ends year five with a lower balance. The ARM has paid $27,782.57 of principal against the fixed loan's $23,034.35, leaving a balance of $372,217.43 against $376,965.65 — $4,748.22 less owed. The reason is simple: at 6.00%, less of each payment is eaten by interest, so more of it pays down the loan — even though the ARM payment is smaller. In the first five years, the ARM wins on every line of the table.

The catch is what happens next. The fixed borrower's payment stays $2,690.83. The ARM borrower's rate — and payment — now follows the market, and the five years of savings can be given back, and more, if rates rise.

Worked Example: What Happens When the ARM Adjusts

Suppose that at the first adjustment, after five years, the ARM's rate rises by 2 percentage points — the typical per-adjustment cap — from 6.00% to 8.00%. The remaining balance is $372,217.43, and 25 years of the loan remain. The payment is recalculated on that balance, at 8.00%, over the remaining 25 years.

The new payment is $2,872.83 a month. That is $474.63 a month more than the $2,398.20 the borrower paid for the first five years, and $182.00 a month more than the fixed-rate borrower's $2,690.83. The ARM's advantage has flipped into a disadvantage in a single adjustment — and the rate can adjust again the following year, up to another 2 points under a typical cap structure.

To see the full stakes, imagine the rate stays at 8.00% for the remaining 25 years. The ARM borrower would pay $143,892.13 in the first five years, then 25 years of payments at $2,872.83 a month — a lifetime total of $1,005,742.47. The fixed-rate borrower pays $968,697.19 over the life of the loan. In that scenario, the ARM ends up costing $37,045.28 more than the fixed loan, despite five years of savings. This is an illustration, not a prediction — the adjusted rate is not predictable, and it could also fall — but it shows how quickly the arithmetic turns once the fixed period ends.

And 8.00% is not the worst case. Under a typical 5-point lifetime cap, the ARM starting at 6.00% could eventually reach 11%. At 11%, the payment on the $372,217.43 balance over the remaining 25 years would be $3,648.15 a month — $1,249.95 a month more than the borrower paid in the first five years. Nobody can say that will happen, but any borrower considering an ARM should ask one question before signing: could I afford the payment at the lifetime cap?

Who Should Choose a Fixed Rate?

A fixed-rate mortgage is the right choice for most buyers, most of the time. Choose it if any of these describe you:

You plan to stay in the home for many years. The longer you keep the loan, the more the ARM's early savings are exposed to later adjustments. If you will still be in the home in year six, seven or ten, the fixed rate's certainty is worth more than the ARM's discount.

Your budget has little slack. A fixed payment lets you plan years ahead with confidence. If a $474.63 jump in the monthly payment — the example above — would strain your budget, the ARM's risk is not worth its $292.63 a month of early savings.

You value certainty over a gamble. A fixed rate is a promise: $2,690.83 a month, every month, until the loan is gone. An ARM is a bet that rates will stay low or that you will be gone before they matter. Some borrowers are comfortable with that bet; most sleep better without it.

The ARM discount is small. In this guide's example, the ARM starts 1.11 percentage points below the fixed rate (6.00% against 7.11%). When the gap between fixed and ARM rates is narrow, the savings are small and the risk is the same — which makes the fixed rate the better deal. The gap changes with the market, so compare the actual rates available to you on the day you borrow. The Loan Comparison Calculator puts two loan options side by side on the same screen.

Who Should Consider an ARM?

An ARM is not a bad product — it is a specialized one. It can be the right choice when the borrower's plans genuinely match the loan's structure:

You are confident you will sell or refinance before the fixed period ends. This is the classic ARM case: a borrower who knows they will move within five years, for work or family reasons, and will never face an adjustment. The $17,557.41 saved over five years is real, and the adjustment risk never materializes. But be honest about how certain the move is — job plans change, housing markets freeze, and a move that was certain can become impossible at exactly the wrong time.

You expect your income to rise substantially. A borrower early in a career with a steep, reliable pay trajectory may be able to absorb a higher payment later. The key word is reliable — expected raises are not guaranteed ones.

You can afford the payment at the lifetime cap. If the worst-case payment of $3,648.15 a month in the example above would still fit your budget, the ARM's risk is manageable, and the early savings are a genuine bonus rather than a gamble.

You have a large financial cushion. A borrower with substantial savings can handle an adjustment, refinance on their own timetable, or pay the loan down faster. For that borrower, the ARM's lower rate is an opportunity; for a borrower stretched thin, it is a hazard.

The Risks of an ARM

Payment shock. The most immediate risk is the jump itself: $474.63 a month in the example, and potentially more at later adjustments. Budgets built around the initial payment can break when the adjustment arrives — especially because the adjustment often coincides with a period when money is already tight.

Refinancing may not be available. Many ARM borrowers plan to refinance before the adjustment. But refinancing depends on things outside your control: if rates have risen, the new fixed rate may be as high as the adjusted ARM rate; if home values have fallen, you may not have enough equity to qualify; if your income has dropped or your credit has slipped, you may not qualify at all. A plan that depends on refinancing is a plan with a single point of failure. Our guide to whether you should refinance your mortgage explains when refinancing actually pays off.

Caps limit the damage; they do not prevent it. A 2-point per-adjustment cap sounds reassuring, but 2 points on a $372,217.43 balance is a $474.63 monthly increase — and the cap allows another 2 points the following year. The lifetime cap of 5 points allows a payment of $3,648.15 a month. Caps turn a cliff into a staircase, but the staircase still goes up.

Complexity. An ARM has more moving parts — index, margin, caps, adjustment dates — and more ways to be surprised. Borrowers who do not understand exactly when their loan adjusts and by how much are the ones most likely to be caught out. If you cannot explain your ARM's adjustment terms to someone else, you are not ready to sign it.

Questions to Ask Your Lender Before You Choose

Whether you lean fixed or adjustable, these questions will sharpen the decision. Ask your lender — or run the answers through the Loan Comparison Calculator — before you commit:

What is the margin, and which index does the ARM follow? The margin never changes, so it sets your rate's floor relative to the market. The index tells you what your rate follows — most ARMs today use SOFR.

What are the caps — initial, periodic and lifetime? The typical structure is 2/2/5, but your loan's caps may differ. Get them in writing and work out the worst-case payment yourself.

What would my payment be at the lifetime cap? This is the single most important number for an ARM borrower. If you cannot afford it, the ARM is too risky for you, whatever the initial rate.

How long is the fixed period, and how often does the rate adjust after that? A 7/1 or 10/1 ARM gives you more time than a 5/1 — at a higher starting rate. Match the fixed period to your honest timeline.

Is there a prepayment penalty or a conversion option? Some ARMs charge a fee for paying the loan off early; some let you convert to a fixed rate. Both change the math of selling or refinancing.

The decision comes down to a trade. The fixed rate costs $292.63 a month more at the start and buys you certainty for 30 years. The ARM saves you $17,557.41 over five years and asks you to accept whatever the market does after that. For most buyers, the fixed rate is the right trade. For a few — those who will truly be gone before the adjustment, or who can afford the worst case — the ARM is a reasonable, money-saving choice. Whichever you choose, make it with the numbers in front of you, not the monthly payment alone.

Sources: Rate figures in this guide are the Freddie Mac Primary Mortgage Market Survey results for the week ending November 12, 2026 — 30-year fixed 7.11%, 15-year fixed 6.45%; Consumer Financial Protection Bureau guidance on adjustable-rate mortgages (index, margin, caps and payment shock). All payment figures in this guide were computed from the standard amortization formula on a $400,000 loan; ARM cap figures (2% per adjustment, 5% lifetime) are typical structures and vary by loan — always check the caps on your own loan documents. Last reviewed: 14 November 2026.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between a fixed-rate and an adjustable-rate mortgage?

A fixed-rate mortgage keeps the same interest rate and monthly payment for the whole loan. An adjustable-rate mortgage (ARM) starts with a lower rate for a fixed introductory period — 5 years on a 5/1 ARM — then adjusts up or down with the market, based on an index plus a fixed margin.

How much cheaper is a 5/1 ARM than a fixed-rate mortgage?

On a $400,000 loan, a 5/1 ARM at 6.00% costs $2,398.20 a month for the first five years, while a 30-year fixed mortgage at 7.11% costs $2,690.83 a month. The ARM saves $292.63 a month, or $17,557.41 over five years — but the rate adjusts after that.

What happens when my ARM adjusts?

The rate is reset to the index plus your margin, within the loan's caps. In our example, a 2-point rise from 6.00% to 8.00% after five years — on the remaining balance of $372,217.43 — raises the payment from $2,398.20 to $2,872.83 a month, $474.63 more than before.

What is the maximum my ARM payment can go?

It depends on your loan's lifetime cap, typically 5 percentage points above the starting rate. On a 5/1 ARM starting at 6.00%, the rate could reach 11%, which would make the payment $3,648.15 a month on the $372,217.43 balance remaining after five years. Check the exact caps on your own loan documents.

Is a 15-year fixed mortgage better than a 30-year fixed mortgage?

It costs less overall but more each month. On a $400,000 loan, a 15-year fixed at 6.45% costs $3,473.44 a month and $225,219.94 in total interest, while a 30-year fixed at 7.11% costs $2,690.83 a month and $568,697.19 in interest — a saving of $343,477.25 for a payment $782.61 a month higher.

Should I choose an ARM if I plan to move in five years?

It can make sense if the move is certain — you would save $17,557.41 over five years on a $400,000 loan and never face an adjustment. But plans change, so only choose the ARM if you could also afford the adjusted payment. In our example, a rise to 8.00% would mean $2,872.83 a month.

Last updated: